How to get rid of the caravan, and any future caravans, without stationing the US military at the border. From Robert Ringer at lewrockwell.com:
People are often surprised when I tell them I believe in open borders … in theory, that is. That’s right, the libertarian side of me believes that a person has a natural right to live wherever he pleases.
Stop and think about that for a moment. Why should a bunch of corrupt politicians and bureaucrats be able to keep you from living in the country of your choosing? Or make you jump through hoops for the honor of legally settling there?
All good theoretical stuff, but, unfortunately, reality has a way of overwhelming theory, and the dominant reality of our age is that a significant number of the earth’s inhabitants believe they have a right to violate your freedom. I’m not just talking about political thugs and bureaucrats, but their envy-crazed followers as well. Thus, the reality of illegal immigration is that it has the potential to destroy a civilized country.
That said, if the United States were to declare undocumented residents ineligible for any form of government assistance, that would be a reality that would change everything. I’m talking about food stamps, unemployment benefits, and healthcare (yes, including emergency room services) — literally, all forms of public assistance — not to mention free education and myriad other government programs.
Some other actions that would change the reality of the illegal-immigrant landscape include:
- Immediately terminating the United States’ absurd anchor-baby policy and have it adjudicated by the Supreme Court once and for all. Babies of non-citizens born in the United States are in no way, shape, or form covered by the 14th Amendment, which was adopted in 1868 specifically to protect the children of former slaves.
- Passing legislation to end the visa lottery and chain migration.
- Meting out steep financial penalties against employers who hire undocumented workers.
With these policies in place, a border wall would become unnecessary. If all incentives to enter the United States illegally were removed, there would be no reason for anyone to want to come here.
It’s not that these solutions are difficult for politicians to understand. The problem is that they do not want to understand, because Democrats are after new voters and Republicans are after cheap labor for their big donors.
As to the “caravan” invasion now making its way to the United States, solving this problem is already covered by Title 8, Chapter 12, of the U.S. Code. That’s right, the president already has unrestricted emergency powers to require all non-citizens arriving at our border to be turned away, regardless of sex or age and regardless of their reasons for wanting to come here. (Amnesty requests, of course, should be considered only if they are applied for at an American embassy in another country.)
Now, I can just hear sanctimonious liberals screaming that Robert Ringer is cruel and unfeeling. Sorry, but I’m not intimidated by hysterical rhetoric intended to shame. I consider myself to be a very compassionate person, certainly far more compassionate than any liberal.
My compassion, however, goes first to American citizens and legal residents who are suffering. There’s only so much compassion to go around — because there’s only so much wealth to go around — and common sense dictates that charity begin at home.
Allowing tens of millions of uneducated, unskilled foreigners to enter the United States illegally is the cruelest thing that can be done to poverty-stricken Americans, homeless Americans, mentally ill Americans, and especially veterans who fall into one or more of these categories.
Then there’s the Dirty Dem canard of insisting that the illegal-immigrant problem could be solved if the United States would just use its financial resources to boost the economies of third-world countries. This, of course, is ridiculous. We’ve given these countries billions of dollars of aid over the years, yet they are poorer than ever.
Let’s get real here: Most of the money we send to third-world countries ends up benefitting, directly or indirectly, the ruling classes. Do we really want to further enrich corrupt politicians and their allies for oppressing their own people?
It’s not that complicated: Corrupt politicians are the main reason why the people of most Central American countries — and, indeed, most countries throughout the world — have been living in poverty and violence for centuries. Short of invading their countries and forcing our system of government on them — which we already know doesn’t work — the reality is that there is nothing we can do to improve the lives of their citizens.
Worst of all, liberals would have us believe that we have no right to enjoy freedom and prosperity while others are suffering. This emotion is called envy — the desire to bring others down to one’s own level of misery.
Envy has been around since the beginning of time, but it was Barack Hussein Obama who popularized it and gave it a much higher profile than it had ever before enjoyed in America. As a devout Marxist from his earliest years, once in office he immediately set about apologizing to other countries for America’s flaws and putting in place policies that were intended to strip America of its economic and military dominance.
I feel sorry for every person living in a country where poverty is rampant, where human rights are nonexistent, and where there is no due process. Nevertheless, none of this is the fault of the United States — and certainly not the fault of its individual citizens. True, most of us are lottery winners by birth, but there is no rational reason to feel guilty about it.
Whether the fake caravan(s) now making its/their way to our southern border ends bloody or peacefully, it’s time to implement the common-sense policies I have outlined in this article. Additionally — and emergencies powers of the president aside — what is needed is unambiguous, non-negotiable legislation that makes the United States policy on illegal immigration crystal clear, to wit:
Any undocumented person arriving at any border of the United States, regardless of age, sex, or country of origin, must immediately be refused entry. No courts involved. End of discussion.
Either we take such an unyielding stance or, by default, meekly submit to the dissolution of the United States of America. History teaches us that empires fall apart when their rulers and their citizens become soft, and Americans have become very soft. Now, thankfully, we are being forced to make a choice, and for that I must thank the organizers of the fake caravans. What shall it be?
Am I being too subtle?