Renegotiating NAFTA Is A Good Idea – For Mexico, by Frances Cuppola

Notwithstanding President Trump’s rhetoric, NAFTA has not been that good a deal for Mexico. Frances Coppula asks some good questions. From Coppula at forbes.com:

President Trump is not happy with the North American Free Trade Association (NAFTA). During the Presidential campaign, he described it as the ‘worst trade agreement the U.S. ever signed’. He blames it for the loss of large numbers of manufacturing jobs across the border to Mexico, where wages are lower. According to the White House website’s new page on trade, ‘blue-collar towns and cities have watched their factories close and good-paying jobs move overseas, while Americans face a mounting trade deficit and a devastated manufacturing base.’

At the same time, President Trump complains about the flow of migrants across the border from Mexico to the US. They take American jobs and American money, apparently. So, he plans to build a wall to stem the flow, and make Mexico pay for it. Exactly how he plans to make Mexico pay for it is as yet unclear: suggestions range from a 20% tax on American imports from Mexico (which my colleague Tim Worstall was quick to point out would in practice be paid by American businesses and consumers), to a withholding tax on remittances from Mexicans working in the U.S.

I sympathise hugely with the Americans who feel that they are losing out. Well-paid manufacturing jobs have indeed declined in the last decade or two, partly replaced by poorer-paying service jobs. But something is not right here. If all the good jobs have gone across the border, how come so many Mexicans have come to the U.S. to work? We should not kid ourselves that this is an easy option. The Mexican border is already heavily policed, and just about the only open route is a long and dangerous desert crossing in which many migrants lose their lives. Why would so many people risk that crossing, if all they had to do was wait for the good jobs to come to them?

To continue reading: Renegotiating NAFTA Is A Good Idea – For Mexico

Advertisements

One response to “Renegotiating NAFTA Is A Good Idea – For Mexico, by Frances Cuppola

  1. I googled “what is the average wage in Mexico?”:

    “One in seven Mexican workers earn the average minimum wage of 65.58 pesos ($5.10) a day or less, national statistics office INEGI says. The average hourly wage in Mexico – home to Carlos Slim, one of the world’s richest men – is 31.3 pesos ($2.43).Jun 2, 2014”

    I would have thunk the author might have used such a number somewhere.
    As well as education levels comparing all those NAFTA job vs. working in America. As well as comparing ….several other things.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s