Ann Coulter is Wrong on Controlling Facebook, Twitter and Google, by Michael S. Rozeff

Foes of the social media companies and their censors are using pretzel logic to try to justify the imposition of the First Amendment on them. However, ties to the government don’t make a private company part of the government, and the First Amendment applies to the federal government and no other entity. From Michael S. Rozoff at lewrockwell.com:

Ann Coulter says

“We need to apply the First Amendment to social media companies like Twitter, Facebook, and Google, because it is a public square, and there is precedent for that and it’s gotta be done…”

I present arguments against her suggestion. I realize fully that these companies have important connections to government including contracts, data sharing and products being developed that further the surveillance state. My argument against Coulter’s suggestion is pertinent to speech, which was her concern, not these other links.

Coulter is speaking out of emotion, confusion, needless desperation and ignorance. The First Amendment restricts Congress. It cannot be “applied” to speech on social media company platforms or to these companies themselves. They are not government. They are private associations. A corporation is a nexus of contracts accomplished by private persons. Her suggestion is impractical, unconstitutional and anti-freedom.

Coulter is actually calling for the government to enforce diversity of speech within these companies. Her diversity agenda is directed to speech, not other matters like hiring; but it’s no different in kind than the government controls that leftists demand when they advocate diversity or extend the idea of non-discrimination into areas where it doesn’t belong.

What Coulter wants is actually not free speech but its opposite, which is “fair” access to speech on social media platforms or “equal opportunity” to speak on these platforms. She wants non-discrimination by these media among those proffering speech. This is not free speech as exercised by the companies. A media platform or site or operation would not be allowed to shape a social communications product adhering to a given non-diverse or exclusive viewpoint. Coulter’s suggestion rules out companies devoted on political matters to particular audiences. There could not be companies devoted to conspiracy theories, fascist ideas, communist ideas, conservative ideas, progressive ideas, socialist ideas, etc. Diversity in speech enforced by government is not free speech at all, whether based upon the First Amendment or any other amendment or provision.

To continue reading: Ann Coulter is Wrong on Controlling Facebook, Twitter and Google

Advertisements

One response to “Ann Coulter is Wrong on Controlling Facebook, Twitter and Google, by Michael S. Rozeff

  1. This man is eloquent enough to sound smarter than he is, but calling “fair access to speech” the OPPOSITE of free speech is really testing my patience.

    Also “apply the first Amendment” is probably just a colloquial shrift for a simple law that forbids discrimination.

    He argues that conservatives are just like liberals if they want diversity of thought instead of diversity of skin colour. We don’t hate enough to see this argument fly. Fail.

    The hyper-libertarian argument also does not fly. After ALL other unnecessary regulation is removed, we can argue if this tiny little law would be too much regulation.

    “Plenty of companies have had bad leadership and gone down the tubes.” How many had worldwide domination over what people even THINK? How many kings have gone down without a revolt? Just by heart attack? No, sometimes the powerful must be bothered and libertarians are not blind to the most obvious things.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.