Tag Archives: Depression of 1920-1921

The Economic Superbowl: 1920-1921 versus 1930-1931, by George F. Smith

How to stop a depression in it’s tracks, and how to prolong one. From George F. Smith at lewrockwell.com:

It’s been said there’s no such thing as a controlled experiment in the social sciences, including economics.  But we had something close to a laboratory experiment back in 1920-1921 and 1930-1931.

In each of these periods there was a depression.  Unemployment was high – for awhile — it was higher in the 1920s than in the 1930s.  Prices were falling in both periods.

In the 1920-21 depression, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York crashed the monetary base, thereby reducing the money stock, and jacked interest rates to record highs.

In the 1930-1931 depression, the federal reserve gradually increased the monetary base and lowered the interest rate.

In the 1920-21 period the government slashed spending and allowed nominal wages to fall.

In the 1930-31 depression the government increased spending and deficits while pressuring industrial leaders to maintain wage rates.

Tax Policies

Coming out of World War I the highest marginal income tax rate was 77%.  First Harding, then Coolidge (following Treasury secretary Andrew Mellon’s advice) lowered tax rates steadily in the early 1920s.  By 1925 the highest tax rate was around 25%.  Tax receipts began to climb, as people stopped playing defense and looked for ways to grow their income.  As incomes increased, so did tax revenue in spite of the lower rates.

In 1932, Hoover pushed through one of the highest peacetime tax increases in U.S. history.  A person making above a million dollars in 1931 could keep 75 cents on the dollar; a year later the amount plunged to 37 cents.  In the lowest bracket, rates more than doubled.  Along with this were countless taxes on items that had never been taxed.  From 1931 – 1933, revenue from the individual income tax dropped by more than half.  By 1933, the economy was at the depth of the Depression.

Continue reading→

1920: The Crash That Cured Itself, by Pedro Almeida Jorge

After World War I, there was an epic financial and economic crash that was righted in less than two years. What did the US government do? Very little. From Pedro Almeida Jorge at austriancenter.com:

The Spanish Flu of 1918 is an event that, unsurprisingly, is being revisited by many observers today. And yet, at the same time, another major event occurred a century ago which we would also do well to remember: namely, the largely forgotten economic depression of 1920.

We all hear, from time to time, about the ghost of the 1929 Crash, of the dreadful decade of the Thirties, of the Great Depression from which the world (supposedly) only recovered at the cost of a new World War. It is even likely that, in the COVID-19 context we currently face, many people believe that, unless all national and international governments and organizations move ahead with drastic measures, we are condemned to a similar fate. Nonetheless, the depression of 1920 can provide us with a starkly different picture.

After the end of World War I, some months of high profits and renewed expectations followed. Unfortunately, due to the gigantic inflation and government controls introduced during the war, as well as the deaths caused by that same war and the pandemic that followed, a great economic readjustment was unavoidable, which eventually came along in 1920.

Renowned financial analyst James Grant, author of the book The Forgotten Depression: 1921: The Crash That Cured Itself, provides shocking data for the United States. Grant tells us that the Federal Reserve index of industrial production fell by 31.6% from 1920 to 1921. In comparison, in the crisis years 2007-09, it “only” fell by 16.9%. And with respect to the unemployment rate, Grant estimates that it may have reached as high as 15.3%.

Meanwhile, according to Grant, “over the course of 12 months, wholesale prices plunged by 36.8 percent, consumer prices by 10.8 percent and farm prices by 41.3 percent (for speed of decline, not even the Great Depression would match the break of 1920–21). The Dow Jones Industrial Average, then comprising 20 stocks rather than today’s 30, crested in November 1919 at 119.62 and bottomed in August 1921 at 63.9, for a peak-to-trough decline of 46.6 percent.”

Continue reading→